By The Central data Commission (CIC) has allowed the Centre to withhold a listing of documents and precious material condemned by a central agency throughout the 1984 operation at the Golden Temple in Punjab during which 576 persons, as well as Army personnel, were killed.
An RTI human, Gurvinder Singh Chadha, had demanded from the Union Home Ministry list of all the fabric condemned throughout the operation and its gift standing yet as all records associated with the operation and list of all the persons World Health Organization died throughout the operation conducted by the military to flush out militants holed up within the Golden Temple in Amritsar.
Without giving the list and therefore the specific details of the condemned material, the ministry had aforesaid in its RTI response to Chadha that “about 4000 documents/books/files and gold /gold ornaments, silver/silver ornaments, precious stones currency, coins etc. were recovered by a central agency throughout the Operation suffrutex. The articles and documents were handed over either to SGPC or to the govt of Punjab”.
“As per records offered with this workplace, 493 terrorists/civilians and eighty three Army officers were killed in Golden Temple space in June,1984,” the house ministry more aforesaid.
Dissatisfied with the denial of specific data concerning the condemned material, Chadha filed the primary attractiveness among the ministry before a senior official World Health Organization upheld the denial of knowledge invoking Section eight 1(a) of the RTI Act.
The Section permits the govt to withhold data, revealing of which might prejudicially have an effect on the sovereignty and integrity of Asian nation, the safety, strategic, scientific or economic interests of the State, relation with a distant State or result in incitement of Associate in Nursing offence.
During the second attractiveness before the Central data Commission, the best judgment body in RTI matters, Chadha declared that a satisfactory response wasn’t however provided on points associated with records of Operation suffrutex and a listing of fabric condemned throughout it.
The ministry aforesaid a degree wise response was provided to Chadha however the main points wanted pertained to tip, the revealing of that might prejudicially have an effect on the security and security of the country.
Agreeing with the house ministry’s read, data Commissioner Y K Sinha command Chadha has wanted “vague, ambiguous and generic information” that can not be disclosed in terms of the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005.
“Hence, no more intervention of the Commission is secure within the matter,” Sinha aforesaid.
The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) has been stern the come of the artefacts, allegedly got rid of by the military throughout Operation suffrutex in 1984.
Last year in June, SGPC cabinet minister Roop Singh had aforesaid the holy scriptures, artefacts and historical books, that were a part of the Sikh Reference Library, were got rid of by the military throughout the operation.
When asked that a neighborhood of media had reported that the Centre had came back the artefacts to the SGPC, Singh had claimed that solely some copies of historical books were came back.
He had aforesaid still an outsized amount of fabric and written copies of the Guru Adi Granth were with the Centre. PTI
